IdeasCuriosas - Every Question Deserves an Answer Logo

In Physics / High School | 2014-10-01

A mountain climber stands at the top of a 50-meter cliff hanging over a calm pool of water. The climber throws two stones vertically 1 second apart and observes that they cause a single splash when they hit the water. The first stone has an initial velocity of +2.0 meters per second. What will the velocity of each stone be at the instant both stones hit the water?

Asked by metcalfh

Answer (3)

One of two things is true about this question: EITHER it can't happen as you've described it, OR you've left out some vital information.
-- IF the first stone was thrown downward with an initial speed and the second one was dropped from rest 1 second later, then the second one can never catch up with the first one, and they can never hit the water together.
-- IF the first stone was thrown downward with an initial speed, AND the second one was released 1 second later, AND they actually do hit the water together, THEN the second stone must have been given an initial downward speed greater than 2 m/s, otherwise it could never catch up with the first one.
Note: The masses and weights of the stones are irrelevant and not needed.
=======================================================
An afterthought . . . . .
If the first stone was tossed UP at 2 m/s . . . that could be the meaning of the prominent plus-sign that you wrote next to the 2 . . . then it rises for (2/9.8) second, then begins to fall, and passes the mountain climber's hand on the way down (4/9.8) second after he tossed it, falling at the same 2.0 m/s downward.
From there, it still has 50m to go before it hits the water. 50 = 2 T + 1/2 G T² 4.9 T² + 2 T - 50 = 0 T = 3 seconds
The first stone hits the water 3 seconds after passing the mountain climber's hand on the way down at a downward speed of 2.0 m/s. In that 3 seconds, it gains (3 x 9.8) = 29.4 m/s of additional speed, hitting the water at (29.4 + 2) = 31.4 m/s .
This is all just a guess, assuming that the 2.0 m/s was an UPWARD launch. Maybe I'll come back later and calculate the second stone.

Answered by AL2006 | 2024-06-10

a) First stone, Vf₁ = 31.38 m/s
b) Second stone, Vf₂ = 34.81 m/s ;

Answered by Edufirst | 2024-06-11

The final velocity of the first stone when it hits the water is approximately 31.34 m/s, while the final velocity of the second stone is approximately 19.62 m/s. Both stones hit the water closely together despite being thrown at different times. This results in a combined splash upon impact.
;

Answered by Edufirst | 2024-09-03