IdeasCuriosas - Every Question Deserves an Answer Logo

In History / Middle School | 2014-11-11

Do you agree with Plato's vision of the ideal state in "The Republic"?

Asked by hannahhadley11

Answer (3)

I do not because it is his dream and it would not be the best in a society today, and would have definitely fallen in the ancient world. Did you notice that philosophers, such as himself, were at the top of the society? It would be hard to have a government like that because it is easier to have a democracy so people are less likely to rebel and are encouraged to make their own decisions. In plato's version, there were kings and philosophers. Good question, though. Thanks for the opportunity to answer a fun question. :)

Answered by Lizzy99 | 2024-06-10

Yes I agree with his vision if the ideal state

Answered by hamilton | 2024-06-10

Plato's vision of the ideal state in The Republic hinges on the concept of philosopher-kings who govern with wisdom and virtue, ensuring each individual fulfills their societal role for harmony. However, this model faces criticism for potentially sacrificing individual freedom and promoting authoritarian rule. Modern perspectives often favor democratic systems that allow for personal choice and collective governance.
;

Answered by Lizzy99 | 2024-10-01

Related Questions in History

[Answered] What did the Puntans form to establish their own New World colony? A. the Mayflower Compact B. the Virginia Company C. the Massachusetts Bay Company D. the Jamestown settlement

[Answered] For each item listed, identify whether it was a provision of the Land Ordinance of 1785 or the Northwest Ordinance of 1787. Banned slavery Reserved a section of land for public schools Divided land into townships

[Answered] Heavily recruited from members of the construction trades, this unit of the military helped build installations at home and abroad during World War II. What was it called? A. Builders' Brigades B. Seabees C. Construction Cadres D. Military Masons

[Answered] What was true of the first settled communities in Ancient America? A. They developed egalitarian social relations B. They practiced slash and burn agriculture C. It led to increasing pastoralism D. It led to increasing urbanization

[Answered] Did the Progressive Era changes, like breaking up big companies, giving women the right to vote, and making new government rules, really fix the problems caused by big cities and factories? Why or why not?