IdeasCuriosas - Every Question Deserves an Answer Logo

In Biology / High School | 2014-05-19

Many residents in a small town have developed a bacterial infection. Two students hypothesize that the bacteria are coming from the town's drinking water. They look for the bacteria in water samples from the lake that supplies 80 percent of the town's drinking water. When they find no bacteria, the students conclude that the town's residents are not getting the bacteria from their drinking water.

Which is a source of error in the students' experimental design?

Asked by YaelHochstein661

Answer (3)

The students only tested the drinking water supplied by the lake. This 80% may not contain the bacterial infection, but the other 20% from unknown sources(which they didn't account for in their conclusion) may.

Answered by Taleya | 2024-06-10

d. Other sources of drinking water were not tested for bacteria ;

Answered by akposevictor | 2024-06-13

The flaw in the students' experimental design is that they only tested water from the lake, which supplies 80% of the town's drinking water, without examining other possible sources of drinking water. Testing only one source can lead to an incorrect conclusion that the drinking water is bacteria-free. A comprehensive approach should involve testing all potential water sources to draw a valid conclusion.
;

Answered by akposevictor | 2024-10-09