1. What is the reason why surface particles of Saturn are used to disprove the nebular theory?
2. Suppose the fate of the sun to become a white dwarf happens soon, how will it affect the conditions on Earth?
Answer (2)
Reason why surface particles of Saturn are used to disprove the nebular theory:
The nebular theory suggests that the solar system formed from a large cloud of gas and dust. One of the issues with the nebular theory relates to isotopic compositions. Some particles or samples, like those found on Saturn or its moons, have isotopic compositions that are different from those predicted by the nebular theory, suggesting alternative processes may have been involved in their formation. Specifically, anomalies in the distribution of certain heavy elements or isotopes can indicate processes such as local supernova events influencing their formation, which the standard nebular model does not fully account for. Researchers study the isotopic and elemental compositions of particles within the Saturn system to refine current models of solar system formation and address any discrepancies with the original nebular theory.
Effect on Earth if the Sun becomes a white dwarf:
Should the Sun eventually become a white dwarf, this process would occur over billions of years through stages, involving expansion into a red giant and then shedding layers into space until only a hot core remains. If this were to happen, the Earth would experience dramatic changes:
Red Giant Phase: Before becoming a white dwarf, the Sun would expand into a red giant, possibly engulfing the inner planets, including Earth, or at the very least, significantly altering Earth's orbit.
Loss of Solar Mass: As the Sun loses mass during this phase, the gravitational hold on the planets would lessen, likely causing Earth to move to a further orbit.
Climate Changes: The increase in solar size and heat during the red giant phase would make Earth uninhabitable long before it becomes a white dwarf due to runaway greenhouse effects and increased solar radiation.
White Dwarf Phase: Once the Sun is a white dwarf, it would no longer produce energy through nuclear fusion, drastically reducing the heat and light it provides. This would plunge any remaining planets, including Earth, into a deep freeze.
Surface particles from Saturn challenge the nebular theory due to their unusual isotopic compositions, suggesting different formation processes. If the Sun were to become a white dwarf, Earth would undergo dramatic changes due to the Sun's expansion and loss of mass, leading to an uninhabitable climate and eventual freezing conditions. Such transformations would occur over billions of years, significantly impacting any remaining life on our planet.
;
